Illegal collection of Event Charges by the society

-
July 20, 2019

The Secretary,
Saket CHS LTD.,
Thane West

CC: The Dy Registrar of Co-op Societies,
Thane City.
- for information and keeping you in the loop.

Sir,

While perusing my half yearly bill, I find that there is an item by name of " Event Charges" which the society is collecting.

On questioning, I was told that this is actually Cultural Charges under a new name.
This collection is illegal and violation of the byelaws and should be stopped immediately.
Basically, I don't know who started this when the AGM last year not to collect it.

The law states:

If we try to find out authority of the managing committee to demand funds to run the society i.e, to maintain property and provide amenities and services, we have to go through Bye-Law No. 67 TO 72 in Chapter VIII. LEVY OF CHARGES OF THE SOCIETY.
Bye-Law No 69(b) carries a mandate that “The committee shall fix in respect of every flat the society charges on the basis laid down under the bye-laws-law No. 69 (a)”
If we browse through the list of items of society charges including Contribution to Funds (Repair Fund and Sinking Fund), we do not come across any item under which
“Charges/fund for functions and welfare of the society” can be clubbed so that we can collect that from the members as a compulsory charge.
One can argue that there is a non-specific head of item of “the society charges”
namely item No. (xiv) “Any other charges : As may be decided by the general body of the society at its meeting.”
But before naming one item namely “Charges/fund for functions and welfare of the society” under (xiv) “Any other charges : As may be decided by the general body of the society at its meeting.” we will have to ensure that there is nothing in the Bye Laws that touches “upon welfare of the society”
With open mind we have to look at two other Bye Laws namely Bye-Law No 5(d) and Bye-Law No 149(b)(iii).
Bye-Law No 5(d) “To undertake and provide for, on its own account or jointly with a co-operative institution, social, cultural or recreational activities” Bye-Law No 149(b((iii)”To allocate to a common welfare fund, such part of the profit, as the annual meeting of the general body may determine, to be utilized in furtherance of the objects specified in the bye-law No. 5(d).”
Combined reading of the two clauses cited above provide an answer that voluntary welfare activities cannot be undertaken by calling upon members to make a compulsory contribution.
Hence, immediately stop demanding this illegal contribution.

Regards,
Dayanand Nene
Member, Saket Managing Committee

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Code of Conduct for Repairs and Renovation of Members Flats in Saket CHSL.

-
Code of Conduct for Repairs and Renovation of Members Flats in Saket CHSL. Dear Member, You may be aware that a large number of flats in the society are undergoing Repairs and Renovation at any point of time, which are carried out many times without proper permission from the society. Over the years, these rampant and extensive repairs have resulted in: 1.     Altering the elevation of the building. 2.     Altering the original plan of the flat. 3.     Damaging the building structure. 4.     Inconveniencing the neighbors. Your Committee is in the process of obtaining Occupation Certificate (OC) from the Thane Municipal Corporation and any such flats who have altered from the basic plan may not be given OC by the TMC – and the society wont be able to do anything in this regard. For your information, i f member wants to do internal structural changes in his flat, he has to obtain approval from Municipal Corporation and a society NOC. If such changes were made without
Read more

Society cannot charge or demand money / donation for the Cultural/Festival Expenses from their members/residents.

-
23/10/2017 Dear Saketians, Read the following carefully. It is going to have a impact on our society from now on. Post the 2014 amendments to the byelaws, Society cannot charge or demand money / donation for the Cultural/Festival Expenses from their members/residents.  The Society cannot implement such Resolution in AGM / SGM and put burden of contributing any money on all the members including the members who are not interested to participate, even though such Resolutions are passed. For Social, Cultural or Recreational activities; Society should use the Reserve Fund as described in Byelaw 147(b)iii, iv and utilise it as indicated in Byelaw 5(d). Byelaw 147(a) After providing for the interest upon any loans and deposits and after making such other deductions as required under Section 65(1) and 66 of the MCS Act 1960 and Rule 49A of MCS Rules 1961, twenty five percent (25%) of the net profit of all the business carried on by or on account of the Society, shall be
Read more

Introduction to the concept of Antyodaya of Pandit Deendayal Upadhyay

-
Image
Dear Friend, The BJP is currently conducting a " Vistarak Yojana" - introduction / spread of the party's ideology to the people. Through personal contact, door to door campaign, letters, mails and meetings, party leaders, office bearers and karyakartas are contacting people on occasion of the party ideologue Pandit Deendayal Upadhyay ji's  birth centenary celebrations. This letter is a part of that endeavor. Introduction: Pandit Deendayalji  Upadhyay was the leader of the Bharatiya Jana Sangh from 1953 to 1968. A profound philosopher, organiser par excellence and a leader who maintained the highest standards of personal integrity, he has been the source of ideological guidance and moral inspiration for the BJP since its inception. His treatise Integral Humanism, which is a critique of both communism and capitalism, provides a holistic alternative perspective for political action and statecraft consistent with the laws of Creation and the universal needs of
Read more